Home/Hastings/McDonald Brummer
All lawyers in Hastings

McDonald Brummer

2.6(5 reviews)Poor (-72%)
06 876 5261
203 Karamu Road North, Hastings 4122

Review Summary

Clients express serious concerns about David Brummer's handling of estates, including allegations of fraud, poor communication, ignoring executor requests, and making false statements to the Law Society. One client warns to be cautious, reporting that Mr. Brummer changed his story and lied to facilitate a sibling's misappropriation of estate funds. Another client describes a four-year nightmare with undisclosed loans and unaddressed questions. However, a single 5-star review praises David Brummer as knowledgeable and patient, particularly in dealing with difficult family dynamics. Overall, the reviews are overwhelmingly negative, highlighting distrust and dissatisfaction.

Generated from 5 Google reviews and NZ Law Society data

Why Choose McDonald Brummer?

Client Reviews

2.6
5 total reviewsPoor (-72%)
5 star
1
4 star
0
3 star
0
2 star
1
1 star
3
K
Kerry Harpera year ago

We used David a few years back and found him old - yes, but oh so wise. He was very knowledgeable and patient, especially when dealing with an insane family member who told lies after lies. Thank you David for all of your help, it was greatly appreciated.

N
Natalie McLagan3 years ago

Communication was shocking. Office staff were helpful but I think Brummer needs to retire. He forgot conversations and facts. My aunt would have been disappointed in how hard it ended up being sorting her estate. Suggest you try Jodi at bannister von dadelzen.

A
Andrew&Olga McCluniea year ago

Warning, be cautious when dealing with Mr Brummer. One of my siblings has just confessed and apologized for grabbing a large amount from our deceased father's estate to buy her house. Mr Brummer had to change his story and lie to the family / Law Society to get that fraud over the line. I reported Brummer to the Law Society informing him that meetings had been recorded (audio) and lying was not an option. Because he was guilty, he refused to tell the truth and was permitted to remain silent. The Law Society argues that even if a lawyer commits fraud against his clients, the Law Society has the legal right to take no further action. The truth would have interfered with their predetermined decisions, so no need to look at any evidence. In conclusion George can do whatever he likes with his clients, no one will touch a senior well-connected lawyer. I wrote to the L.S. President to inform him what is going on behind his back. I attached my letter and their response in the photo gallery. The L.S. President has currently stepped down while being investigated for advising the destruction of evidence.

S
Steve Normanairstreamnz4 years ago

Did my best friends fathers' estate. Brummer ignored executors requests to send out the Will, meaning beneficiaries couldnt contest before probate. Very poor communications. $250K loan not documented or disclosed, made multiple false statements to law society when investigated. A 4 year nightmare for family and still not completely settled. Based on evidence I have seen I would personally avoid this company at all costs.

A
Anna “SouthernGirlNZ”3 years ago

🙄😔 Did Dads Estate. Executor of Estate wasnt kept in line to be truthful ( major beneficiary) Loans and bank with savings were not investigated or looked into. I asked questions that weren't answered. Documents used that we're unsigned and dated and nothing to do with Estate that the Deceased person didn't know about but was used. Extremely frustrating and Dad would be appalled.

Free service

Not sure McDonald Brummer is the right fit?

Tell us what you need and we'll match you with the best Hastings lawyer for your situation — free.

Minimum 50 characters — the more detail, the better we can match you.

Your details are shared only with the matched lawyer. No spam, no obligation.

Get in Touch with McDonald Brummer

Ready to discuss your legal needs? Reach out directly.